Echeveria Vs. Graptopetalum: Right here’s How To Distinguish Them

Echeveria vs. Graptopetalum: Here’s How to Distinguish Them
Echeveria vs. Graptopetalum: Right here’s Methods to Distinguish Them –

As a result of there are such a lot of styles of succulents out there, many followers of those crops wish to study to determine the kind of succulents by finding out the traits of the plant itself. Some are so distinctive that they are often readily recognized, whereas different succulents are so comparable they are often simply confused with different varieties.

Echeveria (“Hen and Chicks”) and graptopetalum (“Ghost Plant”) have some key similarities, however should you look intently at some necessary options of every one, you’ll be capable of inform them aside.

Each kinds of succulents are identified for stunning rosettes, thick leaves, and spring flowering. Echeveria is greatest recognized by its rosettes on brief stalks and spoon-shaped leaves. Graptopetalum is greatest recognized by the trailing vines of rosettes that develop on lengthy stalks and stems.

Though these very fundamental info about the important thing options of echeveria and graptopetalum might assist you to inform them aside, you’ll most likely want a bit extra detailed info. Preserve studying to learn to actually research the plant you are attempting to determine and work out which kind of succulent it’s.

See additionally: Haworthia Fasciata vs. Attenuata: Methods to Distinguish Them

Evaluating Echeveria to Graptopetalum

Echeveria and Graptopetalum each originate within the Americas. Each function rosettes and can normally flower yearly. As well as, each develop in a desert setting however can nonetheless survive in colder and moister climates.

A cautious research of every plant might help you determine which kind of plant you’re looking at primarily based on its: 

  • Leaves 
  • Rising patterns
  • Flowers
  • Rosettes

Allow us to take a more in-depth have a look at every of the traits of those beautiful desert crops.

Look at Leaf Form, Shade, and Texture

Evaluating the leaves on echeveria and graptopetalum is one helpful method to decide which kind of plant you’re analyzing.

Leaf Shapes of Every Plant

The leaves on echeveria are formed like a spoon, with easy edges, and the leaves might have a slim, pointed tip on the finish. In distinction, the leaves on graptopetalum usually take a extra general pointed or triangular form.

Each echeveria and graptopetalum have pretty plump, chunky leaves in comparison with the skinny leaves you could discover on some succulents, so the thickness of the leaves is not going to assist you to inform these two kinds of crops aside.

That stated, the leaves on graptopetalum are normally a bit thicker than these on echeveria. Nonetheless, the distinction is one you most likely received’t discover while you’re studying methods to inform these crops aside.

Distinguishing Differing Leaf Colours

Leaf colour will also be a useful method to distinguish echeveria from graptopetalum. Echeveria leaves might have a very wide selection of colours, together with: 

  • Blue
  • Grey 
  • Silver
  • Yellowish-pink
  • Even pink

The leaves of the graptopetalum usually tend to be solely: 

Though after they develop in an open space with direct daylight, they might be extra yellow or pink.

How Leaf Texture is Completely different

Lastly, the feel of the leaves may also assist you to distinguish echeveria from graptopetalum. The leaves of echeveria are nearly at all times easy and will have a waxy coating. Often, echeveria has a fuzzy leaf. 

In distinction, the leaves of graptopetalum are extra distinctive. They’re coated with pruinose, a white, powdery substance, which supplies the plant a gray-white look that led to its nickname, “ghost plant.”

Watch out to not contact the leaves of a graptopetalum as you attempt to determine it; the pruinose may be broken should you contact it.

See additionally: Treating Molybdenum Deficiency in Vegetation: Right here’s How

Echeveria vs. Graptopetalum
Echeveria vs. Graptopetalum: Right here’s Methods to Distinguish Them –

Contemplate the Plant’s Development Sample

Echeveria is often identified by the title “Hen and Chicks” due to the best way it grows. The “hen” right here is the principle plant, or “mom plant.” Because it grows, you’ll see smaller crops rising across the base of the principle plant – the “chicks” clustering across the hen.

Should you see this kind of development sample, you’re most likely taking a look at echeveria, though another succulents members of the Crassulaceae household additionally show this sample.

Probably the most notable facet of the graptopetalum’s development sample is its lengthy, vinelike stems. Whereas the echeveria, a extra mature plant, may also develop lengthy stems, the echeveria’s stem will develop tall. In distinction, the graptopetalum’s lengthy stems will hold down over the perimeters of your pot or planter or unfold alongside the bottom floor if it’s rising within the floor. 

Along with the expansion and stem sort sample, you would possibly wish to have a look at the dimensions of the plant that can assist you determine it. In fact, you could not know the way mature the particular plant you’re analyzing is, so the plant’s dimension might not inform you a lot. 

Nevertheless, it might be useful to know that graptopetalum can develop anyplace from 6 inches tall to a foot tall and in 14-to-20-inch extensive clusters of crops. Echeveria is mostly smaller, maxing out at 12 inches excessive and 12 inches extensive. 

In different phrases, a really massive plant might be graptopetalum. Nonetheless, there’s a vital overlap within the sizes of the 2 kinds of crops, and general dimension will not be useful in distinguishing one from the opposite.

See additionally: Succulents with Lengthy Stems: Right here’s What to do About Them

Evaluate the Vegetation’ Flowers

Each echeveria and graptopetalum flower yearly, within the spring and early summer season. As well as, they often have equally coloured flowers (white, orange, pink, pink, or yellow).

Nevertheless, there may be one key distinction within the flowers that may assist you to correctly determine which kind of plant you’re investigating: 

  • The flowers on echeveria are bell-shaped 
  • The flowers on graptopetalum are star-shaped 

In fact, you may solely use flowers to tell apart the crops if it’s the suitable time of 12 months!

Measure the Rosettes

Figuring out the dimensions of the rosettes on the succulent might assist distinguish echeveria from graptopetalum, however not at all times. The rosettes on echeveria are typically between ¾-inch and 20 inches in diameter, which is a big vary!

In distinction, the rosettes on graptopetalum have a a lot smaller dimension vary, rising between 2 and 5 inches in diameter.

As a result of this latter vary lies inside the dimension vary, you’d see on echeveria, should you see a plant with a 2- to 5-inch rosette, you can not inform from the final dimension which kind of plant you’re perusing. 

Nevertheless, if the rosette is smaller than two inches or bigger than 5 inches, the plant is probably going echeveria, not graptopetalum.

See additionally: Methods to Make an Aeonium Department Out: 5 Issues to Know

Fast Reference Comparability Desk

This abstract desk supplies a fast method to evaluate echeveria to graptopetalum throughout a number of completely different dimensions mentioned on this article.

Echeveria Graptopetalum
Leaf form Spoon-shaped, easy edges, generally slim pointed tip Rounded tip or bigger pointed tip/triangle form
Leaf colour Grey, inexperienced, blue, silver, pink, pink Whitish-gray, pale blue, gray-green
Leaf texture Clean, waxy, generally fuzzy Lined in white powder (pruinose)
Stem development sample Usually brief stems; longer stems rise up tall Lengthy stems that develop throughout the bottom or hold down over the facet of the container
Flowers Bell-shaped Star-shaped
Rosette dimension ¾-inch to twenty inches 2 to five inches
Desk Shows a Fast Comparability of Echeveria And Graptopetalum –

The Plant Might Be A Hybrid

Echeveria and graptopetalum are such comparable crops that they’re generally cross-pollinated to develop the hybrid plant x Graptoveria. The “x” within the title signifies a hybrid succulent. 

So, it isn’t stunning that it may be exhausting to inform these two kinds of succulents aside.

See additionally: High 16 Finest Vegetable Gardening Books For Newbies

Closing Ideas

With the steerage offered right here, you will have a number of key components you may examine for if you wish to decide whether or not a given plant is echeveria or graptopetalum.

Clear images of the 2 kinds of crops (and their many types) can present further steerage as you’re employed in your identifications. If you wish to seek the advice of images, you could find an amazing echeveria gallery right here. As a bonus, this gallery additionally supplies care ideas do you have to attempt to develop an echeveria at house. Or, have a look at this graptopetalum gallery for examples of the ghost plant.

Whether or not you may accurately determine the succulent you’re looking at, you’ll absolutely benefit from the plant’s magnificence and distinctive qualities!