what soil to use in raised garden beds

what soil to use in raised garden beds

Have you ever ever questioned what sort of raised mattress soil combine is the very best?

I’ve been rising in raised beds from the very starting of my backyard journey. Up till final 12 months, I used native soil on my property to fill them. However once I wanted to search out soil exterior my property for 3 new raised beds final season, I made a decision to conduct an experiment. I examined three totally different raised mattress soil mixes and as we speak I’m sharing the outcomes of my year-long take a look at.

You're reading: what soil to use in raised garden beds

(Click on under to take heed to my dialogue on the Newbie’s Backyard Podcast, or proceed studying.)

*hyperlinks under could comprise affiliate hyperlinks

3 Forms of Raised Mattress Soil

When deciding which raised mattress soil mixtures I needed to check, I selected two widespread mixes that many gardeners select, in addition to a 100% bagged possibility for many who can’t buy elements in bulk. Listed below are the three raised mattress soil blends I examined:

Mel’s Combine

I first selected Mel’s Combine from Mel Bartholomew’s e-book Sq. Foot Gardening. It consists of 1/3 peat moss, 1/3 vermiculite, and 1/3 compost (utilizing as many sources as doable). I used bulk compost (compost I purchased from an area landscaping firm), worm castings, and hen manure from my very own chickens.

Mel's Mix
Mel’s Combine in Raised Mattress #1

Good Raised Mattress Soil Recipe

The second combine I examined is called the “Good Soil Recipe” as really useful by Joe Lamp’l. It consisted of fifty% topsoil, 30% compost, and 20% natural matter. Joe has many various strategies on sources of natural matter, and I used home made compost, hen manure, and worm castings.

Perfect Soil Recipe
“Good Soil Recipe” for Raised Mattress #2: topsoil, bulk compost, and home made compost blended with worm castings and composted hen manure

Bagged Soil for Raised Beds

In my third mattress, I selected a mix of bagged soil. Not everybody has entry to bulk elements, so I needed to decide on an possibility that many individuals should use. On this mattress, I bought 4 baggage of natural backyard soil, two baggage of natural backyard soil “plus,” (with further natural fertilizers), two 40-lb. baggage of topsoil, and three cups of worm castings. Every little thing on this mattress, you would purchase at your backyard heart.

Methodology of Testing Raised Mattress Soil Combine

In these three mixes, I planted Roma tomatoes — three per 3’x6′ mattress. Every tomato plant I had grown from seed indoors and I planted all 9 of them on the similar time.

First Impressions

Planting in Mel’s Combine was a dream. It was mild and fluffy and great to work with. Irrespective of how a lot rain we acquired (and we had a LOT of rain) it by no means acquired waterlogged nor had drainage issues. I had no weeds within the first month and my tomatoes began out extremely wholesome. However, the elements had been the most costly to buy.

mel's mix for raised bed tomatoes
Mel’s Combine

The mattress with the “excellent soil recipe” didn’t begin out as nice as Mel’s Combine. However, I’ve to contemplate a couple of extraneous elements. First, we had a file spring rainfall 12 months in 2019, and the topsoil I bought for the “excellent soil recipe” appeared to comprise much more clay than I’ve seen with different topsoil mixes. Due to this (from my observations), this mattress didn’t drain properly and appeared to compact after the heavy rains. Initially, my tomato crops struggled and had been smaller than these in Mel’s Combine. I additionally had extra weeds on this soil than within the Mel’s Combine, although that was in all probability as a result of larger proportion of my home made compost.

The bagged soil combine was extraordinarily straightforward to place collectively and, like Mel’s Combine, was a dream to plant in. It didn’t compact or have drainage points within the heavy rain. However, the tomato crops from the very starting barely grew, one thing that continued to be a problem for this mattress.

After 1 Month

The tomatoes in Mel’s Combine grew vibrantly and had been robust with tender leaves. Weeds did begin to develop, however they weren’t too unhealthy.

Mel's Mix tomatoes in raised bed

You might want to know: Installation Guides

The tomatoes didn’t develop fairly as properly within the “excellent soil recipe,” however they did develop persistently.

topsoil raised bed compost mix
Good Soil Recipe

The largest shock was with the tomatoes within the bagged soil combine. These weren’t wholesome in any respect. Lots of the leaves had been very yellow and the crops itself appeared severely stunted. I had deliberate to maintain every thing the identical in all 3 beds. Nonetheless, these appeared so unhealthy that I began watering them with fish emulsion to attempt to save them as a result of I feared I might lose them.

bagged garden soil for tomatoes
Bagged Backyard Soil

Remainder of the Season

The tomatoes in Mel’s Combine continued to be robust and vibrant. I anticipated them to gradual in progress as a result of excessive focus of peat moss. (Once I’ve used potting soil with a number of peat moss up to now, it will get very arduous because it dries out.) Though I saved fixed drip irrigation on the beds through the dry summer time, this combine by no means did compact or dry out as I might have anticipated.

mel's mix tomato

The tomatoes within the Good Soil Recipe mattress ended up virtually catching up with the Mel’s Combine crops. I believe this was in all probability as a result of the rain let up and the crops had been not drowning.

perfect soil mix recipe

Whereas the tomatoes in Mel’s Combine and the “excellent soil recipe” ended up performing properly, I can’t say the identical in regards to the tomatoes within the bagged soil combine. Though they didn’t die as I had feared, they by no means rebounded and by no means appeared wholesome.

bagged garden soil

Whole Yield Comparability Between Raised Mattress Soil Mixes

The largest indicator of the success of any raised mattress soil combine is the whole yield, and this I measured meticulously all through the backyard season.

As talked about beforehand, I grew Roma tomatoes in all of those beds. As a determinant selection that bears abruptly, I may weigh the harvest inside a brief window of time earlier than pulling them up and planting a second crop to check.

Under are the yield outcomes from these Roma tomatoes in every combine, in contrast with Romas I additionally planted in my in-ground backyard. I have to level out, on this specific 12 months, my tomato yields had been decrease general, in all probability as a result of extreme rainfall and my battle with early blight. Nonetheless, you’ll be able to see the marked distinction between the beds.

  1. Mel’s combine: 7 lbs/plant
  2. Good soil recipe: 5.3 lbs/plant
  3. Bagged soil: 1.34 lbs/plant
  4. In-ground Roma tomatoes: 2.59 lbs/plant

You’ll be able to see that my crops in Mel’s Combine did significantly better than every other soil, and the bagged soil combine was fairly disappointing.

Additionally of observe: the Roma tomatoes within the floor suffered extra from early blight, and I additionally planted them barely nearer to 1 one other. Nonetheless, this end result stays constant for my backyard — tomatoes in raised beds usually out-perform their counterparts within the floor soil.

Fall Broccoli

As you see above, my first experiment examined the efficiency of Roma tomatoes in the summertime. For my second take a look at, I planted broccoli. The outcomes of that take a look at differed barely.

In September, I planted broccoli I began from seed indoors each within the Mel’s Combine and the Good Soil Recipe beds. I didn’t have sufficient seedlings to plant them within the bagged soil mattress. I ended up shopping for transplants from a backyard heart and planting them within the bagged soil mattress a few month later.

No matter distinction I noticed between Mel’s Combine and the Good Soil Recipe within the early progress of Roma tomatoes disappeared within the fall-planted broccoli. Each beds carried out extraordinarily properly and produced lush, vibrant broccoli — the biggest I’ve ever grown.

broccoli in raised bed soil mixes

I did have a peculiar fall, nonetheless. A record-October heatwave prevented this lush broccoli from forming heads, and an early freeze in November broken the crops severely. Due to this, I barely harvested any heads from this group.

Read more: what is digging holes in my garden at night

As a distinction, the smaller crops within the bagged soil combine (as a result of I planted them a month later), withstood the chilly snap and went on to supply full, giant broccoli heads. Although the crops themselves by no means grew on the charge that these within the first two mixes did, they produced properly.

Soil Testing

At this level, my solely conclusions could possibly be drawn from observing the expansion of two crops — tomatoes and broccoli. However what would a soil take a look at reveal in regards to the variations between these three raised mattress soil mixes?

Previous to the broccoli planting, I despatched off soil samples to my native cooperative extension service. Right here had been the highlights of the variations between the soil take a look at outcomes:

  1. Mel’s Combine: Ph 5.6 (not stunning as a result of peat moss is of course acidic). It examined “above optimum” on phosphorus, potassium, and zinc, and all different micronutrients examined.
  2. Good Soil Recipe: Ph 6.8 which about excellent for many greens, however maybe slightly on the excessive facet for tomatoes. This recipe confirmed above optimum ranges on phosphorus, potassium, and zinc, and all different micronutrients. Of particular observe, these ranges had been additionally above Mel’s Combine in every. Plus, it had virtually double the calcium of Mel’s Combine.
  3. Bagged Soil Combine: Ph 7.5 — that is very excessive for many greens, particularly tomatoes. It was additionally above optimum on phosphorus, potassium, and zinc, however the ranges had been erratic on a number of the micronutrients. I additionally famous a really excessive quantity of sulfate in comparison with the opposite two and really excessive on calcium.
free garden printables

Speculations in Variations Between Raised Mattress Soil Mixes

I’m not a soil scientist, and I can’t let you know all of the “whys” behind what I discovered from my take a look at. However between the soil take a look at and my very own observations, I’ve some ideas in regards to the variations within the soil mixes.

I believe that Mel’s Combine carried out properly as a result of our spring was so moist and the peat moss didn’t have an opportunity to dry out. As an alternative, the drainage capability of the peat moss proved useful in our wet spring.

I consider the Good Soil Recipe began slowly due to the quantity of rain and due to the excessive quantity of clay within the topsoil I bought. If I had obtained topsoil with much less clay content material, I think about this mix would have rivaled Mel’s Combine and even surpassed it.

The bagged combine is a thriller to me as a result of this model was really useful by a trusted gardening pal, and most of these I’ve requested have had a significantly better expertise with bagged soil. That is additionally why I’m not disclosing the model — I don’t consider my expertise is essentially indicative of all of this model’s merchandise.

So, if that’s the case many individuals get nice outcomes with bagged soil (even natural bagged soil like mine), why had been my outcomes so horrible? I’ve a couple of theories:

It appeared like these baggage of soil had a number of tree bark and maybe it hadn’t damaged down sufficient. As an alternative, because it continued to interrupt down it tied up nitrogen my tomatoes desperately wanted. I additionally marvel as a result of it was all bagged if the soil was lacking a number of the micro-organisms native in soil. Maybe this was why it will definitely corrected itself with the broccoli. Third — and maybe most evident — it was simply the excessive Ph. Broccoli can tolerate larger pH than tomatoes can. And though I can’t let you know which of my theories is right — possibly all three performed a task — I can let you know, I realized a number of classes from this expertise with bagged soil.

Now What?

After having examined these three blends of raised mattress soil combine, what is going to I do with future beds?

  1. Native soil is my favourite. The 12 months that I had the very best progress was once I used soil from one other a part of our property. It labored properly and it’s free.
  2. The Good Soil Recipe appears to have higher longevity due to the quantity of vitamins discovered within the soil and it additionally had a extra impartial Ph. This may be my second alternative if native soil isn’t an possibility.
  3. If I exploit bagged soil once more, I’ll add extra topsoil — much more. I believe extra topsoil would assist stability out the forest materials within the bagged soil and maybe buffer the pH points.
  4. I believe, it doesn’t matter what mix I select, it’s vital so as to add range. I would come with as many sources of compost and natural materials as doable. The higher selection we are able to have with our natural materials the higher!
  5. Though Mel’s Combine carried out higher than I anticipated, it’s not my alternative due to the expense. If I had been to solely construct one small raised mattress, it might show value it, maybe. However as I develop my raised mattress gardens, I simply can’t justify the price of Mel’s Combine when the “excellent soil recipe” (with higher topsoil) has the potential to carry out simply as properly if not higher.
raised bed kitchen garden
When constructing this new raised mattress kitchen backyard, I’ll select a mixture of native soil and Joe Lamp’l’s “excellent soil recipe” based mostly on my experiment with raised mattress soil this 12 months.

I beloved doing this take a look at and I’ll proceed to check in my backyard. I’ll need to see what soil I’ll use in my new beds, however there might be loads of alternatives to check new issues!

How a lot soil you want for a raised mattress?

Another factor you might be asking is how a lot soil will you want in your raised mattress, no matter which combine you select? This helpful on-line soil calculator will get you began.

For a particular calculator on how a lot peat moss, vermiculite, and compost to buy for those who go together with Mel’s Combine, this soil combination calculator will assist you know the way a lot of every to acquire.

What about you? What blends of raised mattress soil combine have labored properly (or not so properly) for you?

You might want to know: 4×8 raised bed vegetable garden layout ideas